EDDM is cheaper per piece, but it mails every door on a carrier route, including renters, homes with new roofs and homes re-roofed last year. A targeted mailing list of owner-occupied homes with old roofs costs more per piece, because you pay for the list and for addressed postage, but most of the spend lands on homes that can actually buy a roof. For a retail reroof company, the number that matters is cost per signed job, and that usually favors the targeted list. Scout Data (ours) delivers lists of owner-occupied homes by roof age and roof condition, with homes already re-roofed taken out.
Disclosure: Scout Data is our product; treat that entry as a maker’s pitch and the rest as our honest read.
What EDDM is and what it costs
Every Door Direct Mail is a USPS saturation product. You pick carrier routes on the USPS map, print flat-size pieces (oversized postcards or flyers that meet the EDDM size rules), bundle them by route and drop them at the post office. No names, no addresses, no list. The carrier puts one piece in every mailbox on the route, or every residential mailbox if you choose residential only.
Postage for EDDM Retail runs around 20–25 cents per piece (USPS, 2026); rates change, so check usps.com before you budget. Print for an EDDM-size piece varies widely with size, stock and run length, often a further 10–25 cents. That makes EDDM one of the cheapest ways to put paper in a mailbox.
The catch is in the word “every.” A carrier route does not care who owns the house, whether the roof is three years old, or whether the owner signed with a competitor last spring. You pay the same for each of them.
What a targeted list costs
A targeted list names the homes first and mails only those. For a reroof program the usual filters are owner-occupied, single-family, an asphalt shingle roof past a chosen age, and homes that have already been re-roofed removed. The list costs money per record, and each piece needs an address printed on it and goes out as addressed USPS Marketing Mail or First-Class Mail. Postage and presort discounts vary with volume and density, and your mail house can quote the exact rate.
All-in, an addressed piece commonly lands somewhere in the 40–70 cent range including list, print and postage, depending on format and volume. That is often double the EDDM figure per piece. The question is what you get for it.
A worked comparison per 10,000 pieces
The numbers below are illustrative, for example only. Plug in your own rates and reply history with the roofing direct mail ROI calculator.
EDDM, 10,000 pieces
- Say 40 cents all-in per piece: $4,000.
- Say a third of the doors are rentals, and a share of the owner homes have roofs under 15 years old or were re-roofed recently. Assume only about 2,500 of the 10,000 doors are owner-occupied homes with an old roof.
- Cost per piece that reaches a likely buyer: $4,000 / 2,500 = $1.60.
Targeted list, 10,000 pieces
- Say 60 cents all-in per piece including the list: $6,000.
- Assume a well-built list puts, for example, 8,000 of the 10,000 pieces on owner-occupied homes with old roofs (no list is perfect: some owners will have sold, some roofs will have been replaced since).
- Cost per piece that reaches a likely buyer: $6,000 / 8,000 = $0.75.
In this example the targeted list costs 50% more in total but about half as much per likely buyer. If both campaigns produce the same reply rate among likely buyers, the targeted campaign books roughly three times as many leads per 10,000 pieces, and a lower cost per signed job. The reverse is also true: if the list you buy is stale and full of roofs that were already replaced, the extra cost buys nothing. That is why it pays to test a roof data vendor against addresses of your own past jobs before you commit a blast.
When EDDM still makes sense
Dense neighborhoods built in one era
A subdivision built over three or four years in the late 1990s or early 2000s, mostly owner-occupied, where few roofs have been replaced yet, can be close to a targeted list on its own. If most doors on a route are likely buyers, the saturation rate wins. The hard part is knowing which routes those are, and that is where a list helps even if you mail EDDM.
Brand awareness
A large reroof company running TV, radio or billboards sometimes uses EDDM to put its name and truck wraps in front of a whole town. Treat that as brand spend, not response spend, and do not judge your targeted campaigns against EDDM reply rates or the other way around.
Neighbor mailers after a job
Mailing the streets around a finished install (“we just replaced the roof at 14 Oak Street”) is a classic. For a handful of streets, a targeted list of the old-roof homes nearby is usually cheaper than a full route, but EDDM is fine when the job sits in a dense block of similar homes.
The hybrid: EDDM where the routes are old, addressed mail elsewhere
The most efficient programs often combine both. Start from a targeted list of owner-occupied homes with old roofs across your service area. Count those homes per carrier route. On routes where most residential doors are on the list, mail EDDM and take the lower postage. On every other route, mail only the listed homes with addressed pieces.
That keeps the saturation discount on the routes that earn it and stops you paying for renters and new roofs everywhere else. It also answers the usual complaint about EDDM, that you pick neighborhoods by gut feel or demographics laid over a map: with a list, the route choice rests on the homes themselves.
How to decide for your market
- Pull a free count of owner-occupied, older homes for your ZIP codes with the homes by ZIP tool to see how mixed your routes are.
- Compare cost per likely buyer, not cost per piece, using your own print and postage quotes.
- Track replies by source code (EDDM versus targeted) and judge each on cost per signed job after two or three drops.
- Read roofing direct mail lists for list filters and old roof mailing lists by age for choosing the roof age cut.
Where Scout Data fits
Scout Data delivers lists of owner-occupied homes by roof age and roof condition, with homes already re-roofed taken out, so each piece goes to a home that could buy a roof this year.
You can take a one-time list for a single blast, or have the list sent to your mail house on the schedule you set. You can also use the same list to pick EDDM routes for a hybrid program. See the retail reroof page or the old roofs dataset for what a list includes.
Frequently asked questions
Is EDDM cheaper than a targeted mailing list for roofing?
Per piece, yes. EDDM skips the list and the addressing, and its saturation postage is lower. Per home that can actually buy a roof, it is usually more expensive, because a large share of the doors on a carrier route are renters, newer roofs or homes that were re-roofed recently.
When does EDDM make sense for a reroof company?
EDDM works best on carrier routes where most homes were built in the same era, are owner-occupied and have never had the roof replaced. It also works as a cheap brand-awareness layer under a targeted campaign, as long as you judge it on cost per job, not on pieces sent.
What is a hybrid EDDM and targeted mail program?
A hybrid mails EDDM only on the carrier routes where a targeted list shows that most homes have old roofs, and sends addressed mail to the old-roof homes scattered across every other route. You get saturation pricing where it is efficient and precision everywhere else.
Hear about the next hail storm in your market
Tell us your ZIP code or city and how to reach you, by email, by text message or both. When hail of 1 inch or larger is next reported there, you get one message per storm for each way you choose, with the homes in its path. Nothing else is sent.