The best way to test a roof-age data vendor is on your own past jobs: pick addresses where you know the truth, send them to the vendor blind, score the answers yourself, then run a small paid test mailing before you commit a full blast to the list. Scout Data (ours) delivers lists of homes by roof age and roof condition, with homes already re-roofed taken out, and you can run this same test on it.
Disclosure: Scout Data is our product; treat that entry as a maker’s pitch and the rest as our honest read.
This guide is specific to roof age. For testing contact data in general, see how to test a vendor with a free lead sample and how to audit a lead vendor.
Why a roof-age test needs your own addresses
A vendor’s sample of homes in your ZIP code tells you the file looks right. It does not tell you the roof ages are right, because you have no way to check a stranger’s roof. Your own job history is different: you know which roofs you tore off, when, and what was under them. That is the answer key.
For a mail program of several hundred thousand pieces, the roof-age filter is what decides whether postage goes to buyers or to homes with a five-year-old roof. A few hours spent on this test is cheap next to one wasted blast.
Step 1: build the answer key
Pull 20 to 50 addresses from your records where you know the roof age, and write the truth down before you contact anyone. A good mix:
- Roofs you replaced. You know the old roof was due, and you know the date the new one went on. Split them: some replaced years ago (the list should show a newer roof) and some replaced recently.
- Roofs you inspected. Inspection notes give you an age estimate and the condition you saw.
- Bids you lost. The homeowner needed a roof and went with someone else. If the job went ahead, that roof is now new, which makes these a good check that recent replacements are caught.
- Known new roofs as a control. A handful of homes you know were re-roofed in the last year or two. A list built for old-roof mail should leave them out or flag them.
Spread the addresses across the towns you actually mail, and include both older and newer neighborhoods. Twenty homes on one street tell you about one street.
Step 2: ask for the addresses blind
Send only the street addresses. Do not say which are your jobs, which were replaced, or what you expect. A vendor who knows the answer key can, honestly or not, tune the answers. Ask for each address back with the roof age or age band, the condition if they offer it, the owner name, and whether the home would be on or off a mailing list built for old roofs.
Step 3: score it yourself
Put the vendor’s answer next to your truth in a spreadsheet and mark each home in one of three columns:
- Right band. The age falls in the same band you know, for example “18+ years” or “replaced in the last 5 years”. Exact years matter less than the band your mail filter uses.
- Wrong. The band is off: a known new roof shown as old, or a roof you know was original shown as new.
- Missing. No answer for that home. A list with many gaps shrinks your mailable count.
Look hardest at your control homes. A recently re-roofed home that shows up as an old roof will get every piece of your sequence. If several controls slip through, the list will waste postage at scale. If you want to understand how roof age is estimated in general, see how to tell how old a roof is.
Step 4: check owner names against title
Roof age is half the record; the name on the letter is the other half. For the same addresses, compare the vendor’s owner name with your contract or with the county assessor or recorder site. Watch for a previous owner (the house sold and the list did not catch it), a tenant’s name on an owner-occupied list, and trusts or LLCs where you expected a person. A letter that names the wrong person reads as junk mail before it is opened.
Step 5: a small paid test mailing
A good score on your own jobs earns the next step, not the full order. Buy a small slice, say a few thousand homes in one or two ZIP codes, and mail it with your normal creative alongside a slice from your current source or a plain neighborhood mailing. Give each its own tracking number or code. Compare returned mail, response, and booked inspections before you send the big blast. The roofing direct mail ROI calculator helps you read the result.
Questions to ask any roof data vendor
- How fresh is the roof information for my market, and how fresh is the owner name?
- What is removed before delivery: recently re-roofed homes, renters, non-owner-occupied homes, my past customers?
- Is the owner name the owner on title?
- Can I test on my own addresses before paying, and can I see the answer for each address, not only a summary?
- Can the list go straight to my mail house, and refreshed before each drop if I mail the same market again?
- What happens if a slice of the list is clearly wrong?
Red flags
- The vendor will not run your addresses blind, or wants you to say which ones are your jobs first.
- Only a summary comes back (“most homes matched”) instead of an answer per address.
- Known new roofs come back as old, or every roof age is simply the year the house was built.
- Owner names that match a previous owner you sold to.
- Pressure to sign for a year before any test, or no way to buy a small slice first.
For a wider view of who sells what, see roofing data providers compared.
Where Scout Data fits
Scout Data delivers lists of homes by roof age and roof condition, with homes already re-roofed taken out, owner-occupied, with the owner on title.
Ask for a free sample in the ZIP codes where you have past jobs and check it against what you know before you buy anything. See the old roofs dataset for what a row contains, or the retail reroof page.
Frequently asked questions
How do I check if roof age data is right?
Use addresses where you already know the answer: roofs you replaced, roofs you inspected, and bids you lost. Send the vendor those addresses without telling them what you know, then compare their roof age with your records, home by home.
How many addresses do I need to test a roof data vendor?
Twenty to fifty addresses is enough to see a pattern. Include a few roofs you know are new, because a good list should leave them out or mark them as recently replaced.
What should I ask a roof data vendor before buying?
Ask how fresh the data is for your market, what is removed from the list before delivery (recently re-roofed homes, renters, past customers), whether the owner name comes from title, and whether you can test on your own addresses before paying for a full list.
Hear about the next hail storm in your market
Tell us your ZIP code or city and how to reach you, by email, by text message or both. When hail of 1 inch or larger is next reported there, you get one message per storm for each way you choose, with the homes in its path. Nothing else is sent.