The return on a roofing mailer is the revenue from the jobs it signed divided by everything the drop cost, and the number to compare two mailings on is the mail cost per signed job. This calculator puts two ways of spending a mail budget side by side: a saturation blast to every home in your area, and a smaller list of owner-occupied homes with old roofs, mailed more than once.
Disclosure: Scout Data is our product and sells lists of homes by roof age. The calculator works with any list, and the result depends only on the numbers you put in.
The pre-filled numbers are an illustration, not a benchmark, a promise or a quote. Put in your own: the print and postage quote from your mail house, what each list cost, and the replies you counted on past drops.
| Mail every home | Old-roof list only | |
|---|---|---|
| Pieces mailed | 300,000 | 90,000 |
| Total spend, mail and list | $135,000 | $74,000 |
| Calls and replies | 300 | 450 |
| Inspections | 150 | 225 |
| Signed jobs | 45 | 68 |
| Revenue | $675,000 | $1,012,500 |
| Cost per call | $450 | $164 |
| Revenue per dollar mailed | $5.00 | $13.68 |
| Mail cost per signed job | $3,000 | $1,096 |
How the calculator works
- Pieces = homes mailed × pieces per home. Total spend = pieces × print and postage per piece + what the list cost.
- Calls and replies = pieces × the share that brings a call. Inspections = calls × the share that books and holds an inspection. Signed jobs = inspections × your close rate.
- Revenue = signed jobs × your average reroof job. Mail cost per signed job = total spend ÷ signed jobs.
The sales rates are shared by both columns on purpose: the same estimators run the same inspections whichever list the call came from. What changes between the columns is who gets the piece, how often, and how many of them call.
What the example shows
As it loads, the first column mails 300,000 homes once at 45 cents a piece: $135,000 for about 45 signed jobs, or $3,000 of mail per job. The second mails 30,000 homes 3 times and pays for the list on top: $74,000 for about 68 jobs, or $1,096 per job. Each piece costs more and the list is not free, yet each job costs less, because far fewer pieces land on renters, new roofs and homes re-roofed last year.
Change one number at a time and watch which one moves the last row. On most programs it is the share of pieces that bring a call, which is a question of who is on the list far more than of the postcard design.
Where to get your own numbers
- Print and postage per piece: your mail house’s quote for the size and class you mail. It varies with volume, format and postage class; saturation rates are lower than addressed mail, so use the rate that matches each column. The trade-off between the two is laid out in EDDM vs a targeted roofing mailing list.
- Pieces that bring a call: calls and replies to the tracking number or code on one drop ÷ pieces in that drop. If your drops share one phone number, give the next one its own before you compare.
- Inspections and close rate: from your CRM, for leads that came from mail. Use the season’s numbers, not your best month.
Choosing the second column
The narrow list is only as good as the homes on it. Owner-occupied homes whose asphalt shingle roof is near the end of its life, with homes already re-roofed taken out, are the ones that can buy this year. How old is old enough is a choice with its own trade-off, covered in old-roof mailing lists by age. Before you trust any list with a big drop, check it against your own past jobs, as in how to test a roof data vendor.
Timing matters as much as the list: when to pull it, print and drop for the spring season is in roofing direct mail spring planning, and how a recurring list reaches your mail house is in sending a roofing mailing list to your mail house. For the wider picture of mailing roofing lists, start with roofing direct mail lists.
Where Scout Data fits
Scout Data sells lists of owner-occupied homes by roof age and roof condition, with homes already re-roofed taken out, ready for your mail house. It is one way to fill in the second column; the calculator does not care whose list it is. More on the list itself is on homes with old roofs and retail reroof data.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good response rate for roofing direct mail?
There is no number worth quoting from someone else’s campaign: it moves with the offer, the piece, the season and above all who is on the list. The one that matters is your own, counted per drop with a tracking phone number or code. Mail to homes that cannot buy a roof this year pulls the average down, which is why the same piece does better on a narrower list.
How do I work out the ROI of a roofing mailer?
Add up everything the drop cost: print, postage, the list and the mail house. Follow the replies to inspections and to signed jobs, multiply the jobs by your average ticket, and divide by the spend. Cost per signed job is the number to compare between two mailings, because a cheaper piece that reaches the wrong homes can cost more per job.
Should the list cost go into the calculation?
Yes, and so should every touch. A targeted list costs money that a saturation mailing does not, and mailing each home three times costs three pieces. Leave either out and the narrow mailing looks better than it is; put both in and the comparison is fair.
How many times should I mail the same home?
Most reroof programs that mail a narrow list send each home two to four pieces over a season, a few weeks apart, because a homeowner who is not ready in March may be ready in May. Put your own touch count in the calculator; each touch adds its full print and postage cost.
Hear about the next hail storm in your market
Tell us your ZIP code or city and how to reach you, by email, by text message or both. When hail of 1 inch or larger is next reported there, you get one message per storm for each way you choose, with the homes in its path. Nothing else is sent.